Rural public health nursing requires more than providing services across large geographic areas. It requires adaptable leadership, strong community partnerships and a workforce equipped to meet local needs. In this episode, a public health nursing leader shares how South Dakota is balancing statewide standards with local flexibility, empowering nurses through professional governance and strengthening care delivery across urban, rural and frontier communities.
Selected Podcast
Redesigning Public Health Nursing in South Dakota
Joel Arriolacolmenares, MSN, BA-HR, RN, PHN
Bill Klaproth (Host): This is Today in Nursing Leadership, a podcast from the American Organization for Nursing Leadership. I'm Bill Klaproth. And today, we're talking about rural public health nursing leadership and how nurse leaders can adapt established leadership and professional practice frameworks to meet the needs of urban, rural, and frontier communities.
With me is Joel Arriolacolmenares, Administrator for the Office of Public Health Nursing Services with the South Dakota Department of Health. Joel, welcome.
Joel Arriolacolmenares, MSN, BA-HR, RN, PHN: Hi, Bill. Thank you for having me.
Host: You bet. Let's start with this, Joel. Your nursing leadership career has taken you through very different environments. How have those experiences shaped the way you approach leadership in public health nursing today?
Joel Arriolacolmenares, MSN, BA-HR, RN, PHN: Well, yeah, yes, Bill. My background includes nursing, human resources, organizational leadership, and military service. And those experiences have shaped how I approach leadership, particularly from a workforce development standpoint, professional practice, and overall organizational improvement. What makes public health nursing especially meaningful to me is the opportunity to influence health outcomes before individuals require more intensive care. And I try and bring that same mindset that I learned in the military in developing the workforce to meet a capability or a need to what I do here in South Dakota.
Host: So, let's talk about South Dakota for a minute. So, South Dakota includes urban centers, you've got rural communities, you've got remote frontier areas. How does that diversity influence the way you think about public health nursing across a state as diverse as yours?
Joel Arriolacolmenares, MSN, BA-HR, RN, PHN: Well, in South Dakota, Bill, geography isn't just a logistical challenge. It actually influences access, staffing, relationships, and how we deliver those services. What I would like to emphasize is that we're a statewide workforce, and you'd think we would have everything standardized statewide, but statewide consistency does not always mean identical service delivery. So, you have to have a degree of local adaptability that's allowed in the models to meet those individualized needs of the communities. So, I think that's kind of what we're up against here with the multiple settings that we have.
Host: So, local adaptability. I like how you say that. So, South Dakota's public health structure, and this is really unique with state-employed nurses embedded in communities across the state. Can you talk about that? How does that structure share both the opportunities and challenges of nursing leadership? Can you explain that whole thing to us?
Joel Arriolacolmenares, MSN, BA-HR, RN, PHN: Yes. Yeah, yeah. We're likely one of the few health departments that have a centralized, you know, public health nursing workforce. That means they're state employed, but they're embedded in local communities. And then, we have different mechanisms by which those communities can help us shape, you know, those programs. Some of them are through support that they lend us like in-kind benefits like office space or resources or personnel. Some just will contribute funding where they can. And that's kind of how we use that state-employed centralized workforce to get after these local objectives where we feasibly can.
The beauty of it is that it is centralized. So, you could make some systemic changes and say, "Hey, this applies across the enterprise." And the bad side about it too is that, well, you do have to allow for that local adaptability. And that's something that you have to balance, you know, when you're introducing a change that might be very particular to one community, but maybe not replicable across another one, especially when resources are involved.
Host: Yeah, I could see where that would be a balancing act. And I know that part of your work has involved introducing professional governance and creating greater nursing ownership of practice decisions. I know that you're definitely working in that area. So, can you explain to us why it's important for nurse leaders to create the environment for professional practice without necessarily making every practice decision themselves?
Joel Arriolacolmenares, MSN, BA-HR, RN, PHN: Yeah. So, well, especially when leading a statewide enterprise, you can't be in every discussion, and you can't be at every single point of service. You also have to respect the fact that we're doing some sort of a nursing care or applying some sort of nursing theory in the field. And that truly is and should be left to the autonomy of the nurse, you know, and their judgment, their professional judgment, their individual competencies.
So as leaders, we have a responsibility to shape that environment, and we are also accountable for that nurse practice environment that the nurses operate in. To give you an example, when a nurse makes an error, you know, whether intentional or not, you're responsible for, you know, looking into it and seeing what caused the error, especially when it deals around, medication or patient safety.
So, you definitely have a responsibility to the environment, but you don't have to dictate everything in there because the beauty of nursing is that you are employing a professional workforce with a skill set. So therefore, you have to create the conditions for them to practice their craft, which is the nursing profession, and exercise their competencies within their licensure.
So, governance is a key point to that. It helps us separate the management and leadership roles while still keeping it nested, to help provide the holistic practice environment for the nurses. And the governance just gives the nurses a great mechanism to represent their viewpoints, their professional opinions, you know, what they see at the point of service and help us make better informed decisions on the programs or the budgeting aspects that ultimately affect their practice environment, whether it be equipment, resources, personnel, future training, or new ventures into different service lines.
Host: So, is it fair to say that governance kind of gives them a framework to operate in?
Joel Arriolacolmenares, MSN, BA-HR, RN, PHN: Yes, it gives them a framework to have input into the organizational decision-making that historically would have been made without their voices. They can let us know what they're seeing on the front line, what interventions are working, what's not working. It also gives leadership a framework that you can give to the nurses and say, "Hey, all this has to be grounded in evidence, and whatever recommendations we're bringing, you know, have to be feasible, we have to budget them, and they definitely have to be measurable." So then, we're working together to improve the whole enterprise, not just working in fragments with great ideas in silos.
Host: So, let's talk a little bit more about frameworks and AONL's competencies. So, I know, again, you've been working to establish nursing leadership frameworks. How have you taken AONL's competencies and how have you adapted them to public health? And in that transition or in that work, what have you learned about translating those frameworks into a rural public environment, a very diverse setting like you have in South Dakota, rather than just simply, "I'm going to take this from another state and plug it in"?
Joel Arriolacolmenares, MSN, BA-HR, RN, PHN: Sure. Although many leadership frameworks originate, like, in the acute care setting or in the hospital setting for nursing, the underlying competencies, like communication, systems thinking, workforce leadership, and professionalism are equally relevant to public health in our setting. So, what we did here were upon me taking this role, we looked at, you know, how are we doing with the practice of nursing leadership and management? Because leadership is also its own practice. But often, what we see is that great nurses get promoted to be leaders, and it doesn't necessarily translate into a great leader.
We'll have nurses who are great at their craft who become managers, but then are too in the weeds to allow the nurses to have that autonomy in the practice environment. So, that was one of the areas that I saw was a good opportunity for us to bring in some frameworks from the AONL and then look at a deliberate effort to develop our management team, our leadership team, and those in those pipelines to really understand the role of the manager and say, "These are our accountabilities as a nursing manager dealing with these areas. And this is what we help to shape that practice environment for the nurses." And then, they do their piece with the governance and with the actual daily operations of the nursing care.
Host: So, public health often succeeds when something doesn't happen, like, an infection is prevented, a disease is caught early, a patient avoids hospitalization. So, how are you approaching measurement so that nurse leaders can demonstrate both the work public health nurses perform and the value that work creates for patients, communities, and the broader health system?
Joel Arriolacolmenares, MSN, BA-HR, RN, PHN: Oh, that's a very good question, Bill. And it's definitely one that could lend to hours of discussion on its own. So in public health, honestly, the bottom line is you have to look at your population health outcomes, and then you have to find a way to pin what's going on, you know, whether it be at the state level for a certain population, down to what your nurses do on the day-to-day in these communities at the individual level.
And then, you have to have multiple measurement points along the way. You know, how is this population doing? How is this community doing? And then, statewide, how are we doing overall?
So, I think in what we're doing here, knowing that we need to tie our efforts to measurement to demonstrate that value for the community in preventing these comorbidities or the things that are ailing our population, like maternal, infant deaths, we really have to look at our program service delivery and the designs there with the measurement of the nurse-client interaction and what that yields.
You know, after an appointment, after two appointments, after three appointments, what do we do to move that continuum of care for the client to mitigate something that is preventable, like you said, that we don't want to happen? So, getting a good baseline of where the population is at the state level, where you can by demographics and where you can by locality, and then being aware of those measurements continually while also trying to design and deliver your interventions with the aim or the goal of bringing those values down for the sake of preventing those events.
Host: For sure. So, you were just talking a little bit about measurement. Is there one outcome or metric that you wish healthcare leaders would really understand better about public health nursing?
Joel Arriolacolmenares, MSN, BA-HR, RN, PHN: What I would have to say is that there's really a host of measurements that you're looking at. You know, I wish we had one golden KPI, you know, key performance indicator, that we can look at a dashboard and say, "We're doing a great job." And in a high level you do, you could say mortality is that way, but any level of mortality that exists is really not acceptable.
You know, so, we have ways to give us indications of how we're doing. But in public health nursing, I believe it's multiple indicators that you have to be aware at simultaneously. And you also have to realize that there's a lot of non-tangible value in the work that we do where the ROI is measured beyond maybe just a cost saving, you know? Because again, like you said, we're trying to have events never happen, you know? So, when hose events do happen, there is a cost, there is a number that we can go off of and saying, "Okay, did we reverse that?" But what happens when you fully reverse it and that number is zero? You know, where do you go from there? I think then it becomes a measurement of sustaining that number at zero. You know, so it definitely evolves, and what I've learned is that there's more than one indicator that you have to be very aware of.
Host: And that is tough to measure when I say public health often succeeds when something doesn't happen. So, how do you measure something that doesn't happen? So, I see the challenges there. So as you look at the work underway around evidence-based practice, professional governance, workforce development, measurement, evolving care models, all those things, what makes you most optimistic about the future of rural public health nursing?
Joel Arriolacolmenares, MSN, BA-HR, RN, PHN: Wow. You're going to get me fired up, Bill, and we're going to go over time. But what makes me most optimistic is that, in public health nursing under a state agency, you really do have an opportunity to fill those fragments in the healthcare model of the United States, and to really prioritize those who are truly in need and not necessarily—you have to worry about finances, but we don't really have to worry about the bottom line, you know? So, I think in that, in itself, is an opportunity to really serve those who are, need to be served outside of the frameworks that exist with commercialized healthcare, because they have their own challenges there with those models.
So, I think it's a very great opportunity to partner, look at the overall holistic health of the state or the population that you're concerned with, and partner to deliberately fill those gaps, and let commercial systems do what they do best, and then let us come into those other areas and fill some of those gaps until they can afford to expand market share or bring out services in a sustainable way into those areas.
So, that's what gets me excited about professionalizing the public health nursing workforce, making sure that they are using evidence in everything that they do, that we're considering measurement, because we do require some investment from state legislators or from the federal government to do the work that we do. And as they identify priorities or they set charters for their states and what they want to see for the population, I'm excited for the opportunities that we can bring to fruition if we have a ready and capable workforce that's, well-equipped and well-resourced and supported.
Host: Well, Joel, I wrote that down. That is a great mission statement. Fill those fragments and help those truly in need. So, I think that really kind of sums it up right there. This has been great, Joel. Thank you so much for your time today. We really appreciate this.
Joel Arriolacolmenares, MSN, BA-HR, RN, PHN: No, thank you, Bill, for having me. Great to see you.
Host: That is Joel Arriolacolmenares with the South Dakota Department of Health. If you found this podcast helpful, please share it on your social channels and check out the full podcast library for topics of interest to you at aonl.org/nursing-leadership-podcast. This is Today in Nursing Leadership. Thanks for listening.