Thinking about supplements for weight, blood sugar, joint pain, or overall health? Learn how supplements are regulated under DSHEA, what the USP seal means, and how to weigh evidence versus risk. Topics include St. John’s wort (enzyme inducer and interaction risks), berberine (low bioavailability but CYP interactions and hypoglycemia potential), red yeast rice (adulteration with lovastatin), kratom (opioid‑like effects, adulteration, FDA warnings), creatine (kidney concerns), and ashwagandha (CNS effects, rare hepatotoxicity). The episode gives tips on how to talk about supplements with patients, reliable online resources to check interactions, and data on safety and risks of popular supplements.
Supplements: Risks, Interactions, and Evidence
Amanda Swain (Host): Welcome to the Penn Primary Care Podcast. I am your co-host, Amanda Swain. And I have with me tonight two clinical pharmacists who I work with personally and I cannot say enough positive things about. Tonight, we're going to be talking a lot about supplements, which I think is a topic that people have lots of questions on.
So, I'm going to go ahead and introduce our guests, and then we're going to get right into the conversation. Jasmine Delk, PharmD, works as a clinical pharmacist in ambulatory care and family medicine. Dr. Delk's professional interests include providing care to underserved populations and the role of pharmacists in resource-limited settings. Nicholas Grillo, PharmD, who our regular listeners may remember from our episode on GLP-1 medications, is a clinical pharmacist also in ambulatory care at Penn Presbyterian Medical Center. Dr. Grillo joined the ambulatory care clinical pharmacy team in 2024 with a focus on weight management and addiction medicine
I was looking up some data on supplements just before coming on, and I was not necessarily surprised to see data that about 60% of adults in the US take some kind of dietary supplement. What I did find surprising was that the use is highest and climbing fastest in older adults, so ages 65 and up. But I think it's really interesting when you think about the why behind people taking supplements, you know, that we are seeing a lot of this with folks that probably are also taking a lot of prescription medications.
And also, in that age group of 65 and older, there's a lot of use of multiple supplements at once, which really gives me a lot of cause for concern. Maybe we can start with the kind of overview of, I guess, you might say how the sausage gets made in a sense of like what are the regulations, if there are any, around supplement creation, like the safety?Like, how does all of that work?
Nicholas Grillo, PhD: Yeah. One of the biggest takeaways is that the supplements that are on the market available at pharmacies, available online, they're not approved by the FDA. So, they don't undergo the same type of testing that prescription medications need to prove safety and efficacy for that specific disease state.
And so, DSHEA or the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act was an act in 1994 that required manufacturers to ensure that products are safe before marketing them, but it's not reviewed by the FDA. So, the onus is on the manufacturers, not a government agency to prove or to show that the product is safe before marketing them.
FDA is involved or can be involved and requests removal of a supplement from the market if it's proven to be unsafe. And patients and anyone really can report adverse effects to the FDA reporting system. And most importantly, this act also established that these supplements cannot claim to treat, cure, or mitigate any disease.
And so, that opens up a lot of question marks and conflicting data oftentimes to the efficacy and safety of various supplements. There is a handful, one or two organizations, most notably USP or United States Pharmacopeia, which is an independent company that sets standards for dietary supplements. So, a lot of times you kind of look for that seal or that label on medication or supplements over-the-counter supplements specifically to see if it's USP approved.
Jasmine Delk, PhD: Yeah, I think the one thing I would take away or take away from what Nick said is that the supplement industry, like, spends a lot of money each year to continue the status quo of this kind of gray area of regulation and not only is it a concern for product quality and safety, it's also because there's no requirement for randomized controlled trials that kind of parse out all the variables that could potentially also impact like what you're looking for if you're taking a supplement that is purported to help you lose weight, but the parameters of the study don't require that patients stop exercising or stop taking other medications like GLP-1s, basically accounting for confounding variables. It's likely that it might be something else. It might be the supplement or it might be a combination of factors including the supplement or it might be completely independent. But because of the trial design of the limited available trials, it's hard to actually say that the supplement is the cause whereas with pharmaceuticals due to the controlled trials, you can establish causation rather than just a correlation.
Host: Right. So, not only are the companies that are producing the supplements not really on the hook for making sure that they're safe, they also don't necessarily need to make sure that they're effective, if I'm hearing you correctly.
Jasmine Delk, PhD: Right. I think, I mean, I'm not trying to get in trouble with any supplement manufacturers. But if it was found that supplements that have all these purported benefits aren't actually, you know, better than placebo at achieving the desired effect, I think that might be not great for, like, someone if they were in the business of selling supplements.
Host: Yeah, absolutely right. I mean, it's in the company that makes the supplements best interest to stay off the FDA's radar, essentially to exist outside of that system of checks and balances, so to speak, involving randomized controlled trials and testing on animals before humans and et cetera, et cetera, because it benefits the business essentially.
And I think that's often what gives me pause with supplements is that I don't feel like I'm on any solid ground with knowing about safety or, I mean, I was talking to a friend about taping this episode and they said, "What brands do the pharmacists that you work with recommend?" And I said, "I actually don't know that they would go out on a limb and recommend a specific brand," because it is really hard to pin down that safety. I mean, is that true, or would you say there are some brands where you feel pretty confident kind of recommending the patients, you know, "Buy that..."
Jasmine Delk, PhD: I'd say those with the USP label are like a good start. But there is always a risk of variations in like product purity. But I think the ones with the United States Pharmacopeia label would be a good start.
Nicholas Grillo, PhD: Yeah, they set those standards independently. So, it kind of gives you a little bit more confidence in saying that there's at least some type of testing to show that the manufacturing process is safe, you know, for that product. And it's safe to take that supplement. But outside of that, with specific manufacturer, specific brands, yeah, it's really tough to say or recommend one.
Host: Yeah. It's a bit of the Wild West out there. I have a lot of patients that say that they've bought things off of Amazon. You know, they may not come in a bottle. It may just be an herbal, you know, that comes in like a little capsule that's been packed. So, it is really hard to know what's what.
So, since we're kind of on the gloom and doom side of supplements, let's just keep going there. So, are there certain supplements that if you hear a patient is interested in taking it or maybe they're already taking it, it really does make you a little nervous? Like, supplements where we really know that there are adverse effects on various body systems
Jasmine Delk, PhD: Well, one classical and that we always learn in pharmacy school is St. John's wort. But a good amount of patients out there are on it, and that would be something that kind of set off my pharmacist alarm bells. And for those of you who don't know, St. John's wort is an inducer of our enzymes, of our drug-metabolizing enzymes. So, it makes them work harder and then it results in decreased drug concentrations of our medications, which could be very significant when you're thinking about things like contraception, antiretrovirals. So yeah, that's one for sure.
Nicholas Grillo, PhD: And there's also categories of supplements that can cause liver toxicity, cardiac toxicity and, like Jasmine said, with a lot of specific drug interactions. And maybe most notably is also bleeding. So, supplements that can increase the bleeding risk, really a high concern for patients on our antiplatelets and anticoagulants.
Host: Is there something that you recommend for patients in terms of, you know, some kind of resource for them if they are considering using a supplement and they need to get hopefully some information about whether or not there's going to be any potential interaction with medications that they're using? Where do you send patients to get that information?
Jasmine Delk, PhD: Yeah. I really like the Memorial Sloan Kettering, it's like a drug supplement database where you can look up a variety of natural supplements or vitamins, and then it will kind of give you an overview of the medications, and then also discuss relevant drug supplement interactions, supplement disease interactions, like concerns that, you know, if you had this condition you might not want to use this supplement.
And I think it's in a readability that's easy for patients and also easy for prescribers to tell their patients about these different medications or these different supplements and medication interactions.
Nicholas Grillo, PhD: Yeah, that's a great one. And then, on the provider end, I think the Natural Products Database, you know, we have it built in on our Lexicomp and up to date. So, I think it's a great resource. Tells you all about supplements, herbals, kind of mechanism of action, and potential considerations. Also really nice, it cites references, kind of if there was any trials, any case series that reported serious adverse effects. It can be linked there as well.
Host: We can definitely put those links in the show notes, because I love having both of those resources at hand. I think you both have brought up really good points about not only do we have to be mindful about supplements interacting with prescription medications, but we also have to be mindful about supplements that might interact with certain diseases, right? So, are there certain conditions that you just kind of want to raise a bit of a red flag about in terms of like if a patient has these issues, like, they really, really want to be cautious with introducing supplements?
Jasmine Delk, PhD: Yeah, I would say like if someone already has some preexisting liver injury or hepatic dysfunction, for example, cirrhosis, lots of supplements can be hepatotoxic and we're not always sure due to limited available data, like we're not always sure what dose is hepatotoxic in patients who have normal hepatic function and even less data about the supplements in patients with decreased hepatic function. So, some of those supplements that are really popular are kava, which can be used for like anxiety, stress, sleep, and things like black cohosh as well. And then, any like green tea extracts can be hepatotoxic as well. Ashwagandha, I believe, is one also, but I'll have to double-check with that. But yeah, those supplements can obviously accumulate more and cause worsening of the patient's preexisting liver disease or induce liver toxicity in someone who doesn't have any preexisting liver disease.
Nicholas Grillo, PhD: Yeah, for sure. Another area that kind of sets alarm bells off is anyone with any type of like cardiac dysfunction, considering blood pressure, heart failure, all that stuff, and patients taking supplements that can worsen cardiac function or at least potentially raise blood pressure. For example, something as simple as caffeine, right? If someone is using or taking additional caffeine plus maybe some energy drinks, maybe additional cups of coffee, getting up to a high milligram dose per day of caffeine maybe unintentionally without even realizing that they're actually getting that much.
Along the same lines as caffeine is a supplement called guarana, it's used as a stimulant. It also can be used to increase energy and potentially for weight loss as well. But high concentrations of, in effect, caffeine in that supplement. So, if you think of a scenario of someone drinking multiple cups of coffee, multiple energy drinks, plus this other supplement to increase alertness, well now add that on top of any type of hypertension or heart-related conditions, and it's a big cause for concern.
Host: Yeah, I definitely see supplements that are advertising as, you know, increase your metabolism, speed up your metabolism. So, it's safe to say that that is probably not something that we want anyone with any underlying heart disease to be dipping into.
Nicholas Grillo, PhD: Yeah, for sure. And one more supplement along the same lines is one called bitter orange. And this was historically sold as like ephedrine alkaloids, which in the early 2000s the FDA banned the sale of. But you can still find bitter orange, and the effect of it is similar to that ephedrine. And the FDA banned the sale of the ephedrine alkaloids due to case reports of heart attacks and strokes and overall increased blood pressure, even in younger patients.
Host: Any other conditions where you really want to be cautious when thinking about introducing supplements because of the underlying disease process or underlying organ dysfunction?
Jasmine Delk, PhD: Patients who have blood clotting disorders or are on blood thinners or what we call blood thinners, anticoagulants like warfarin or apixaban or enoxaparin. Several supplements can increase your risk for bleeding. So, that's things like ginkgo biloba and garlic and ginseng.
Host: Got it. Nick, any last thoughts on that?
Nicholas Grillo, PhD: And it's important, especially on the pharmacy end, to make sure we're asking those questions. Are you taking any non-prescribed medications, any supplements, natural medications, herbals? Rephrasing that in a way to try to spark a patient's memory of kind of what they take maybe not in their pill box necessarily, but maybe it's like in a tea or any other type of beverage that might give us a little bit more information that could impact their condition.
Host: I think it's so tricky because, you know, the marketing for supplements is great. You know, you see the word natural. And that has, in my mind, an entirely positive connotation. If it's natural, it must be safe, it must be good for you. But there are a lot of limitations there, and I think certainly on the patient end of things, it can be tremendously confusing to try and wade through all of that information to figure out what's what.
Jasmine Delk, PhD: I was just going to clarify the four Gs: garlic, ginkgo, ginseng, and the last one I forgot was glucosamine, which is like a osteoarthritis supplement. So, very common in the older population. All increased bleeding risk, though, for patients on blood thinners in general.
Nicholas Grillo, PhD: Yeah. And Amanda, to your point where, you know, it looks like it's natural, it looks like it would be "safer" than a medication. But the only problem with these natural supplements that we don't know, for that specific patient, we don't have a similar comparator. We don't have a patient similar to you necessarily in a randomized clinical trial to say that it's going to be safe or even effective.
Host: There are some supplements out there that have some good data behind their use and that we actually feel pretty confident in recommending.
Jasmine Delk, PhD: Yeah, definitely. I think that is kind of the thing that can be confusing for patients is that we do have some supplements that we have a lot of great data for. But then, we also have supplements that we don't and sometimes those supplements we don't have data for. I kind of think of them kind of riding on the coattails of things that we know we have evidence for, like, folic acid in pregnancy, because folic acid is necessary for our DNA synthesis and vitamin D for vitamin D deficiency in CKD or osteoporosis.
If you have osteoporosis, people are recommended to take calcium and vitamin D. Omega-3 fatty acids for lowering triglycerides, vitamin B12 for deficiency that can lead to like peripheral neuropathy. Fiber is technically a dietary supplement. And that is, you know, one of our low barrier first recommendations for someone with constipation before we pursue pharmacologic therapies or do any other additional workup.
And then, of course, like iron deficiency anemia. Yeah, iron is a supplement. I mean from a pharmacist's perspective, these are a lot of the supplements that are "covered by insurance" sometimes depending on the dose and that not always what to side with the insurance companies, but I think they might at least find utility in paying for it because we do know that these are the ones that are recommended and have some clinical benefits.
Host: Yeah. Those are great points. I think some of those I don't even think of them as in the same category as the supplements that we're spending time talking about tonight, because it's so accepted that we use it. I mean, I immediately I think of vitamin K, you know, giving to newborns to help with the coagulation cascade, right? There's so many things like that that we've just incorporated into medical practice that we don't even really think so much about them being supplements in the same way that we might think about St. John's wort or ginseng.
Jasmine Delk, PhD: Just because we have these supplements that we do recommend doesn't necessarily mean like—well, it's like an asterisk, like recommended when clinically indicated. So, like, that doesn't mean like everyone should go off and start taking B12 if they don't need it, or calcium if they don't need it, or iron or excess fiber, because now that can also lead to issues and unnecessary side effects.
Host: Yeah. But I'm curious what you both feel or advise people about when it comes to like a general daily multivitamin.
Nicholas Grillo, PhD: Yeah, it's not a strong anti-multivitamin. It's not a strong for a multivitamin either. I think considering that a lot of these electrolytes, a lot of the things that are in the multivitamin, you can get from your diet naturally, I like to encourage that upfront. See, like if you have a balanced diet of fruits, vegetables, fiber, proteins, and a wide variety of those, then you'll likely be getting all the nutrients that you need naturally from natural sources, from food that you eat, plus it's providing, you know, nutrition and energy, whereas the multivitamin isn't going to make you feel more energetic throughout the day. So, I think that's where I would start.
Host: So, I'd love to just kind of lob some supplements your way and get your take, because I think there are some supplements that have been around for quite a long time that I think we've been talking about on and off for decades now, and I'm curious what the most up-to-date take on those supplements is. And then, there's some really new stuff that people have a lot of questions about.
And I'd love to go back to one that you mentioned already, which is St. John's wort, which when I was in training, which is going back a couple decades now, a lot of people were talking about because there was still, I would say, a fair amount of mistrust around the SSRIs, and people liked the idea of St. John's wort as this "natural antidepressant." And I'm curious, do you find that it's still being used a fair amount in the patient populations that you deal with?
Jasmine Delk, PhD: In the case where I encounter a patient on St. John's wort, I think the only cases where I have few issues with it as a pharmacist is a patient who's on very minimal meds and almost no medications, because St. John's wort doesn't just impact like any drug enzyme. It impacts the drug-metabolizing enzyme that metabolizes a large percentage of the medications that we take. So, it's highly likely that the medication you're on can be like impacted by St. John's wort.
Now, how much it's going to be impacted and what that will mean for you, that might influence, you know, the degree of sternness I have with requesting that it be discontinued or the, in the case of the patients, that I've asked to discontinue it, one was interaction with antiretroviral therapy. So, that's kind of a no-brainer. Because if you're taking the St. John's wort and it's decreasing the levels of your Biktarvy, for example, now your HIV virus is potentially resistant to Biktarvy, and that could be detrimental.
And the other thing is if you are also on other meds for your mental health conditions, like other serotonergic medications like your SSRIs, your amphetamines for ADHD, tramadol, and St. John's wort is also serotonergic. So, it could theoretically increase your risk of serotonin syndrome. Of course, the risk is likely low. But if you're already on multiple medications that have some serotonergic effects, you get even more close to that possibility happening. And with that, it can also like many other medications that are serotonergic or CNS that work on the CNS system, it can also lower like your seizure threshold.
So, that could be a concern for a patient who has like preexisting seizure disorder, epilepsy, for example, or just on many medications that lower the seizure threshold and that could be as simple as like being on St. John's wort, taking Vyvanse, maybe taking bupropion.
Host: Yeah. So, those are really important points. And I think what you're talking about with the enzyme, you're talking about like the CYP enzyme-inducing system, right? So, anything that affects that will affect the way our liver is metabolizing all kinds of things. So, that is a very important thing to be aware of. Thank you.
Jasmine Delk, PhD: St. John's wort probably not for most people, unless you're literally on no medications at all.
Host: Yeah, beware. Okay, great. What about red yeast rice? This was all the rage back in the early 2000s, and a lot of people really, really didn't want to be on statins. Still, a lot of people don't want to be on statins. And for the people that do their homework, often they come in asking about red yeast rice, or maybe it will be under another name. But when I look at the ingredients, that's essentially the supplement they're talking about. What are things that you think primary care folks should know about red yeast rice?
Nicholas Grillo, PhD: Yeah. I think, for me, when I hear red yeast rice, I think of, number one, either did a patient ever try a statin previously and maybe couldn't tolerate it, maybe tried a couple different statins, and they want to try something more natural. Or two, someone who was diagnosed with hyperlipidemia or perhaps had a cardiac event and doesn't want a medication to treat, think they can either lower LDLs or total cholesterol more naturally with red yeast rice. So, it is a kind of a "natural form of lovastatin," and to lower cholesterol. Some versions of red yeast rice that you can purchase actually contain lovastatin in it. So, it's kind of adulterated with the actual drug to help lower LDLs.
The efficacy level of red yeast rice alone is, in general, less than what we see with our typical statins. And certainly, you know, if there's some statin hesitancy, there's the PCSK9 inhibitors as well. There's other options to lower cholesterol. So really, just trying to find the root causes as to why red yeast rice over other statins or more traditional statins, especially in the cases of patients on other medications.
Host: Yeah, I think going in with the curiosity mindset is a great way to get to this information, right? It's not that we're anti-supplements. It's not that I would say across the board that patients should never take supplements. And I think the way you framed it, Nick, is really helpful, which is let's kind of figure out like what about taking this supplement appeals to you? What do you think you're going to gain from it? Do you have any concerns about it? And then, we can have a much more thorough and educational conversation about it.
And the other thing I just want to say here, because I think it's something we're all likely aware of is, you know, there are a lot of cultures and a lot of traditions that have use of herbal medicines going back thousands of years, right? And I think that is not really what I'm talking about or what we're talking about here today, right? This is not disparaging Chinese herbal medicine or Ayurveda or like all of these really, like, tradition-based medical systems, right? I think when I'm thinking about supplements, I'm really thinking about what are people just going and buying off the shelf in random places? What are you ordering off of Amazon? And how are we really kind of figuring out what's what in that realm?
Nicholas Grillo, PhD: Yeah, I agree. And it's kind of the mindset now of because of the marketing, there's a million ads, commercials, and you think, "Oh, that could help me," rather than this is tradition passed down for generations, right? And so, that's kind of where that kind of piques our interest. It's like, where did you hear about this supplement? And a lot of times, it is TV, internet, TikTok.
Host: Another one that I'd love to hear your take on is saw palmetto. This is definitely something that I hear about more so from older men, because I think there's some association between saw palmetto and some effect for benign prostatic hyperplasia or potentially some link to prostate cancer. So, I'd love to hear your thoughts on that.
Jasmine Delk, PhD: Lots of patients definitely are interested in this medication in terms of, like, BPH benefits. But of course, like, the data is not very strong. And in terms of the pharmaceutical options that can be available for the specific symptoms, I think we at least have the data to support that something like tamsulosin can help much better with that, or I guess not much better. We don't have the data to, say, to compare it. We only have data to compare it to tamsulosin against, like, placebo.
Nicholas Grillo, PhD: The data surrounding the utility of saw palmetto is a little bit conflicting. There's limited data. You can look at some randomized or, I guess, meta-analyses that will show a little bit of improvement in urinary flow rate or peak urinary flow rate. But also, you can probably find just as many random meta-analyses that show that there was no difference than placebo, or if there was a difference than placebo, it's hard to kind of find how much better or worse saw palmetto is compared to our medication options.
Host: Right. Nobody's paying for a study comparing tamsulosin to saw palmetto to control.
Jasmine Delk, PhD: I feel like a lot of patients ask me specifically, as a pharmacist, like, what we think about supplements and, like, is it going to work for them? And usually, like, the general gist is like we're not really sure. Of course, we can say that we don't have randomized control trials, we don't have data. But then, when you have a patient sitting in front of you saying that X, Y, Z supplement is working for them, who am I to argue with their experience of what works for them? So, it's kind of like, as long as it's not negatively impacting your other medications and your other health conditions, that's kind of my general spiel with patients, because, you know, it might work for you. The whole thing is that we don't know, and that's kind of the issue.
Host: Yeah, I think that's a great take on it, right? Kind of like safety first. And beyond that, go do it. And, you know, keep checking back your routine labs. But yeah, sounds okay. I'm kind of thinking now maybe like about other supplements that I tend to get a lot of questions about.
And so, the first one that comes to mind is creatine. And so, creatine, it feels like it's kind of morphed from something that a lot of teenage boys were talking about. And now, it's something, going back to TikTok, that I see in all of these videos about women in perimenopause and menopause and building muscle. So, what is going on with creatine? Is this something that we should be concerned about? And how do you approach that with patients?
Nicholas Grillo, PhD: Yeah, no. I think creatine is definitely increasing in popularity recently. Part of it is because it's more readily available. It's easy. A lot of times it's in powders, kind of similar to like a protein powder. So, you kind of just quickly mix it in into a beverage, and you have the opportunity to increase athletic performance, increase muscle mass especially for more short duration, high intensity exercises. Also, being used more for injury prevention and to speed up recovery to allow your muscles to kind of build back more quickly and decrease the time to recover. There's been some, you know, studies looking at for in addition to the myopathies for any neurodegenerative cognitive disorders or to improve memory as well. And overall, the data is certainly mixed and very limited for those conditions.
Now, the concern with this in terms of common side effects or things to be a little bit worried about, most common side effects are mostly gastrointestinal; weight gain as a result of water retention. But maybe more serious would be the concern for any kidney issues or acute kidney injury, partially due to dehydration and partially because the creatine itself can be nephrotoxic. So if we think of patients with already reduced kidney function already maybe taking a lot of NSAIDs or other medications going through the kidney, that could be a concern and maybe it wouldn't be the optimal time to start creatine for building muscle.
Host: I actually just had a patient in my office, a woman in her early 70s who's in quite good health, who mentioned that she had started taking creatine to help with muscle. And we were doing some labs anyway, and she actually did have an elevation in both her creatinine and her GFR, and I asked her to stop it. And we rechecked, and it was trending downwards, and that's the end of creatine for this patient. We've done the experiment, and now we have the results.
Nicholas Grillo, PhD: And the creatine can be found naturally in seafood and in various meats as well. So, kind of a good compromise is, you know, instead of using the creatine powder, maybe you try to increase or add another meal or two throughout the week with additional seafood or meats.
Jasmine Delk, PhD: The other thing I think about with creatine is, if you think about the gym influencers who are maybe taking creatine or maybe those who want to be like those internet people taking creatine and pre-workout, it's usually like not the only thing that they're taking. They might be combining it with caffeine, and like protein shakes or protein snacks in general, which again, like if you already have pre-existing renal dysfunction could be concerning or other medications that can lead to like dehydration or, yeah, like decreased blood flow, low blood volume, for example, can all can impact that.
Host: Those are great points. So, I want to ask you about some supplements that maybe are not quite as popular or not quite as talked about, but I think are important for people to have an awareness of. So, the first is ashwagandha. Do you come across this very much? And what, if any, safety concerns do you have about that?
Jasmine Delk, PhD: Yeah. That one is another one that I see in, like, the younger age group like lots of marketing for various reasons. It's a root extract of Withania somnifera, which is a plant. And it's known as an adaptogen, which is a word that's thrown around in a variety of supplements and different, like, drinks and teas I see at the grocery store.
Ashwagandha is used for stress, anxiety. It also is thought to be helpful for sleep, athletic performance, recovering from, like, workouts. And some people also can use it for, like, different like thyroid or testosterone support. Support is another word that's used by supplement companies because they can't say that it helps increase your testosterone levels. It just supports. But it's thought to have, like, some GABAnergic activity so similar to, like, alcohol or gabapentin or pregabalin to help reduce anxiety, reduce cortisol levels, might have some antioxidant impacts and anti-inflammatory effects. You can find it in, like, capsules or tablets.You can also find it in teas or seltzers, canned drinks. And it's anywhere between like 300 and 600 milligrams a day from what I saw. There's not, like, an established dose that is known to be effective for each indication, for lack of a better word.
But it's not found in our diet and the concerns that I have with ashwagandha is that it has some CNS depressant effects. So, anything else that you're taking that you might also be taking for your stress, anxiety, or sleep, thinking like hydroxyzine or a benzodiazepine or just any other medication that can cause some sedation, a tricyclic antidepressant, mirtazapine.
So, there's some theoretical additive sedative effects with ashwagandha, which could be desired if someone has some insomnia, for example. But it could also be concerning if the patient is already at risk for falls or is already oversedated throughout the day or has to, like, operate heavy machinery, for example, like a car.
And then, also in addition to having some CNS depressant effects, lowering blood pressure. So, patients also on antihypertensives, and it can also have some concerns with lowering blood glucose. And then, also, hepatotoxic as well. That can happen anywhere between, like, the first few weeks to about three months on the medication or on the supplement. And the hepatotoxicity resolves upon resolution of the ashwagandha.But I thought it was pretty interesting that there's been some reports of liver transplantation needed as a result of this supplement, and that it was actually banned in Denmark in 2023 since their version of their FDA hasn't been able to determine a safe dose for the medication among its increased reports of liver injury.
Host: That brings up something that's really important, right, which is it's not just knowing the name of the supplement or knowing in theory what the supplement is supposed to be doing for you, but also how the supplement is working in our system, right?
So to your point, you know, is there some effect related to GABA, then that's helpful for us to know because then there are people that are taking medications, or is it sedating and so on and so forth.
Jasmine Delk, PhD: And I think like the best thing that a patient can do if they're taking any supplement is just tell someone about it. Like, don't keep it a secret. And maybe sometimes we need to be a little bit better of, like, providing like a safe environment for people to tell their healthcare professional that they're taking supplements. Maybe they had an experience where they were kind of invalidated when they shared that they took supplements, and I think that could be harmful if they don't feel comfortable speaking up about what other things that they're taking.
Host: There are a few supplements that I want to make sure we cover. And one of these you mentioned earlier, Jasmine, which is berberine. Maybe one of you could talk a little bit about what this is, its common uses and, again, are there things that we should be concerned about or that we should really have a heads-up about with patients that are using this?
Jasmine Delk, PhD: So, berberine, it's an isoquinoline alkaloid from Berberis. It's another plant. And it's known to support type 2 diabetes or glycemic control as well as different like weight and metabolic syndromes like PCOS. It can be marketed to patients with that condition, as well as like hyperlipidemia or dyslipidemia.
Right now, in the GLP-1 craze, it's kind of marketed as nature's Ozempic or nature's GLP-1. It's not known to have too much effect on the same pathway as GLP-1s. But it can do some of the same things in terms of increasing insulin sensitivity and inhibiting hepatic gluconeogenesis. And it can also upregulate your LDL receptor expression to help lower LDL. And it is also thought to have some positive impacts on your gut microbiome. It can be found in like tablets or capsules.
The interesting thing is that it has a very low oral bioavailability, less than 1%. All that to say is that it doesn't really get systemically absorbed that well from our body. And because of that, it can be formulated in different ways that increase its bioavailability, which can also increase its risk of side effects which can be diarrhea, constipation, abdominal pain, flatulence, all things that you could get with a pharmaceutical grade GLP-1.
Additionally, it inhibits a good variety of our drug metabolizing enzymes, our CYP3A4, 2D6, 2C9. So, that can lead to some drug interactions there, leading to increased concentrations of the medications that are substrates of those enzymes and therefore possible increased risk of side effects. If you're on other meds that can lower blood glucose, there's an additive risk of hypoglycemia with berberine, as well as risk of low blood pressure.
And overall, if patients are on narrow therapeutic index medications, so medications like warfarin or tacrolimus to prevent organ rejection, that would be very concerning to be on berberine; or things like lithium or valproic acid, medications that we're checking levels for that could be a concern or something that maybe as a pharmacist, I'd want to do some more investigating about supplements if I see that these drug levels are out of range or out of their reference range. Or if a patient comes to me already on one of these medications, I would probably recommend not trying that or at least maybe in certain patients where I feel confident about their ability to have close follow-up and monitoring. But yeah, so it's in the news a lot. And yeah, the main concerns would be kind of drug interactions and would avoid in pregnancy and breastfeeding as well.
Host: I always get nervous when I see something marketed as nature's-insert-pharmaceutical-name-here, right? It just makes me think, well, that's good on paper. But in reality, what are we talking about? Which I think you just gave a great illustration of, which you say, wow, it can have an effect on glucose metabolism. Wouldn't that be amazing if we could have an effect from a supplement that's relatively inexpensive that could somehow be competitive with the medication, the GLP-1s, which are still, for most people, cost-prohibitive outside of insurance. But to your point, it's not that simple.
Jasmine Delk, PhD: Yeah. And it would be great if we could have something that was a tenth of the price of a GLP-1. Yeah, it's very interesting that it has very low systemic bioavailability, but it achieves just enough concentration in the liver to have significant impacts on drug interactions.
Host: So, the worst of both worlds, I would say.
Jasmine Delk, PhD: Yes. Yeah.
Host: Great. Good to know. Okay. So, last but not least, this was on the list that you gave me of supplements that you wanted to talk about, and I'm so glad that you put it on there because I do not know anything about this, and I'm so curious. And I'm talking about kratom, which I would say most of us have probably seen advertised like as like a neon thing in, like, the window of a smoke shop or something. And I've seen it so many times, and I've always wondered, "What is that? Who is using it and why? And it seems like it is probably a safety concern, but I don't know enough to say more than that." So, I would love to hear your take on it.
Nicholas Grillo, PhD: No, Amanda, your instinct is right. If it feels like it might be a safety concern, yeah, you're on the right track. So, kratom is a tropical tree native to Southeast Asia. There's two main psychoactive components to this plant. One is mitragynine and the other is 7-OH. The 7-OH component makes up just about 2% of the natural alkaloid of the kratom plant, but demonstrates much higher mu-opioid receptor potency.
So in effect, what you're getting, kratom with 7-OH products are essentially mu-opioid agonists that are being sold at gas stations, online, and fairly inexpensive as well. So, as you can imagine, people reach for these supplements for pain, anxiety, depression, opioid use disorder, opioid withdrawal among a variety of other conditions. It essentially is just activating the mu-opioid receptors in the brain. And the mitragynine component can bind to serotonin, dopamine, and adrenergic receptors as well, all having activating effects. And in effect, it will have stimulant and opioid effects. They're available in tablets, gummies, like, almost like a five-hour energy drink shot readily available. So, obvious concerns for patients being treated for opioid use disorder or have polysubstance abuse.
Another big concern is that kratom is also a weak CYP3A4 inhibitor, so again, a drug interaction potential there. And also, for patients on concomitant CNS depressants poses a major risk. As you can imagine, because it's hitting the mu-opioid receptors, there's a risk for abuse, dependence, the whole GI symptoms, nausea, vomiting, constipation, dizziness, drowsiness, confusion, tremors, respiratory depression, especially with our high-dose synthetic 7-OH products, which are being added as adulterants into "natural kratom." Then, because of this, opioid overdose and the resulting withdrawal may occur.
Recently in the news, there's been several investigations with recent college students, and their deaths potentially associated to kratom and 70H-containing substances. And so, because of these investigations and these rising concerns, the FDA put out a very serious warning against kratom and 70H products. And in some cases, these products can be adulterated to actually contain opioids, most notably fentanyl as well. So if it has the potential to be adulterated, don't assume it's natural or it's a natural plant-based product. And so, the main goal is to raise awareness that these products, especially if they are adulterated, can cause serious harm and to kind of put the makers and sellers of these products on alert, because they are in essence marketing to think college-age kids. So, very serious, that's had a surge in popularity recently.
Host: Okay. I'm sufficiently terrified. Thank you. was super helpful information. I will be sure to be passing that on to people of all ages. So, thank you both so much. This has been a really wide-ranging conversation. And I think there are a few things that you both said that I want to reiterate for our audience, and then I'm going to ask you if you have any final thoughts, wisdom that you want to impart to us.
So, one note that you both made earlier was about the USP label. So even though we still may not necessarily have the same kind of rigorous testing that we might have for something that's FDA-approved, if a supplement has the USP label, then we can have some confidence in the testing of the facility where it's being made.
The other thing that, again, we'll put in the show notes, is this resource for patients and potentially for clinicians alike, which is through Memorial Sloan Kettering. But that's a nice, like, a repository for information about the array of supplements that are available.
And then, the other thing that I really appreciate hearing from both of you is this idea that like anything else that we're talking about with patients, we really want to be able to have as open and honest a conversation as possible and really just ask questions, because ultimately that's going to benefit the patient and those of us who are taking care of them.
Are there any final points that you want to make sure to communicate to our viewers before we log off tonight?
Jasmine Delk, PhD: I think just like anything that we do for our patients, like trying to take an objective approach, because we never know why someone is turning to a supplement or picking that or what their specific reservations about medications are.
So, approaching it from like an empathetic standpoint and a knowledge-seeking like standpoint of just trying to be curious about why someone might be taking a supplement, why someone might be hesitant to medication, why someone is not hesitant to medication but would love to add supplements.
I think just having us as healthcare professionals, I think we owe that to our patients to have like a tolerant approach to supplements and be accepting of them. because like I said before, they might work for people. It's just that it's kind of set up so we don't really know if it works for people on a population standpoint.
Nicholas Grillo, PhD: And I think the biggest thing or patients interested in taking a specific supplement for a specific condition or even just a multivitamin is understanding where it's being made, looking for that USP seal, and doing a little bit of research, kind of what are the available options for that condition you think you can improve?
And to bring that discussion with your provider as well to see is there any significant safety concerns for me right now or kind of what their thoughts are with starting a supplement.
Host: Great. Thank you both so much, Dr. Delk, Dr. Grillo. It's been a pleasure having you on the Penn Primary Care Podcast. And we will see you back next week. Thanks so much.
Nicholas Grillo, PhD: All right. Thank you.
Jasmine Delk, PhD: Thank you.